Gillard My School tests flawed
2nd August 2010

Gillard boasts that the My School website and school league tables are her proudest achievement - all based on the New York model introduced by Joel Klein.  The latest research proves that the New York model has failed!

Courier Mail
Edition 1 - First with the newsMON 02 AUG 2010, Page 021
Flaws test Gillard's proud boast
By Kevin Donnelly

PRIME Minister Julia Gillard recently nominated the MySchool website as one of her proudest moments in politics.

But should it be? When she was education minister, Gillard justified making tests public, league tables and naming and shaming schools by citing the work of New York City's head of schools, Joel Klein.
Gillard visited New York and was involved in inviting Klein to Australia.

Unfortunately, just released research from New York shows the Klein initiatives, which Australian schools are being forced to follow, have led to falling standards, a dumbed-down approach to the curriculum and a host of unintended consequences.

Such were concerns about falling standards that the State Board of Regents, the body responsible for education in New York, commissioned research to evaluate the impact of Klein's testing and accountability regime - one that Gillard touts as world's best.

One of the main criticisms against high-stakes testing, like New York's model and Australia's national literacy and numeracy tests at Years 3, 5, 7 and 9 (NAPLAN), is that standards are dumbed down to make sure more students succeed.

This is exactly what has happened in New York.
It is true that under Klein more students are passing the local tests but, as noted in a recent Board of Regents media release: ``The problem is that those exams didn't sufficiently test students' abilities - the bar was set too low.''

The result? Students who achieve good results in the Grade 3-8 state tests fail to perform well in later examinations and during first year at college. The New York research concludes, ``students who scored `proficient' on state exams found themselves unprepared, without remediation, to do the work required of them when they reached college''.
The Board of Regents further noted that ``not only is the Klein testing regime very lenient'', it is also dishonest and misleading as ``no good purpose is served when we say that a child is proficient when the child is not''.

New York is not the only education system where testing and naming and shaming schools are under attack.

In the UK, after the National Association of Head Teachers and the National Union of Teachers organised a boycott of tests for 10 to 11-year-olds earlier this year, the new Conservative Education Secretary Michael Gove has agreed there are flaws in the current testing system and that it needs to be reviewed.

Many of the criticisms of the New York system of testing are mirrored in a UK research project, The Cambridge Primary Review, including teachers teaching to the test, with subjects such as music, history, literature and physical education being dropped from the curriculum.

One wonders what Prime Minister Gillard makes of the fact that when she boasted during her recent debate with Opposition Leader Tony Abbott about beating the teacher unions and getting the MySchool site established that the Channel 7 worm went into negative.



Archived News

> Curriculum review endorsed
> School discipline
> National curriculum review announced
> It's ability not SES
> SES not the issue
> Return phonics to the classroom
> Alan Jones interview - school funding
> Gonski a threat to non-government schools
> Greens Party policy a danger
> Gillard's education plan empty rhetoric
> Education failing boys
> PM's Press Club Speech
> Gonski review cultural-left
> Gonski review cultural-left
> News
> UK primary curriculum back to basics
> Ban competition in sport
> Gonski a danger to non-government schools
> Gonski a danger to Catholic and independent schools
> Gonski a danger to Catholic and independent schools
> Gonski report penalises non-government schools
> Don't attack non-government school students
> Responses to OECD report miss the mark
> Choice and diversity in education benefits all
> Greens Party intent on destroying non-government schools
> Government schools elitist and discriminatory
> The left has lost the culture wars
> National testing for mums and dads
> Gillard's educrats attack non-government schools
> Fairfax Press biased against non-government schools
> ALP's multicultural policy contradictory and flawed
> Failed education revolution
> School funding review
> A real education revolution - what does it take?
> PISA test and Australia - what does it mean?
> MySchool website used to attack non-government schools
> Greens Party to cut funding to non-government schools
> Old school is best
> Coalition best for education
> Greens Party to destroy non-government schools
> Gillard's school autonomy proposal all spin
> Gillard My School tests flawed
> Liberals introduce school vouchers
> Non-government schools deserve funding
> Muslim curriculum biased
> Gillard still a closet socialist
> NAPLAN tests flawed
> Draft national curriculum dumbed down and PC
> ALP education revolution fails
> Yesterday, the ABC..
> Australia's national curriculum debate
> Australia has high social mobility
> British schools shadow minister likes Dumbing Down
> US academic critical of high stakes tests
> University entry must be based on merit
> Quadrant has just released a..
> Hi, much of the Rudd/Gillard..
> Hi, the Spectator has a brilliant..
> ABC radio's Counterpoint has an..
> In case you missed it..
> Rudd's education revolution denies school autonomy
> Donnelly book launch
> Rudd's education revolution 3 out of 10
> US experts say no to value-add

Sign in and have your say


Latest Blog

1st January 1970

Read Full Post!


$20.00 plus $6 postage
(within Australia).

Latest News

Gillard My School tests flawed
2nd August 2010
Gillard boasts that the My School website and school league tables are her proudest achievement - all based on the New York model introduced by Joel Klein.  The latest research proves that the ...

Read entire article...

Sign up to our Newsletter...