ESI BLOG

In the following article posted..
23rd November 2009

In the following article posted on the National Times site I argue why Catholic and independent schools must be properly funded.

Independent schools are bastions of equality and tolerance
November 23, 2009 - 6:41AM

Do Catholic and independent schools help alleviate racism or do they promote unfair discrimination and division?

Those opposed to government funding to non-government schools argue the second. Over the past year or two a number of critics have argued that whereas government schools promote the common good, tolerance and respect for difference, non-government schools fragment society and weaken social capital.
Sydney University Professor Andrew Jakubowicz argued earlier this year that faith-based schools undermine the "whole edifice of social cohesion and modern citizenship". Mounting a similar critique, the head of the Australian Education Union, Angelo Gavrielatos, argues non-government schools "exacerbate social divisions".
Only this week, Catherine Deveny accused non-government schools of being bastions of privilege and failing the equity test.
Not only do critics rarely, if ever, provide evidence supporting their claims, recent research suggests they are wrong. In a just-released report by the Foundation for Young Australians, The Impact of Racism on the Health and Wellbeing of Young Australians, the evidence is that students who attend Catholic schools are 1.7 less likely to experience racism when compared to students in government schools.
The report states, "only 53.9 per cent of participants from Catholic secondary schools reported being subjected to racist treatment, whilst over 76 per cent of students from both types of government schools indicated experiencing some form of racist treatment".
Additional evidence that Catholic and independent schools successfully promote social cohesion and tolerance is found in an analysis of the 2005 Australian Survey of Social Attitudes by education commentator Andrew Norton.
Norton's analysis concludes that those who had attended Catholic schools rated higher than those from government schools in terms of social involvement and a commitment to the types of values and attitudes needed for social stability.
It should also be noted that the social composition of Catholic school communities largely mirrors that of government schools. Instead of only serving the privileged, many Catholic schools exist in low socio-economic communities with a strong multicultural profile.
The rationale for strong, properly funded and autonomous non-government schools is not just about social cohesion and reducing discrimination. Central to any democracy is parents' right to choose where their children go to school and to have them educated according to their morals and beliefs.
Surveys show that the reason parents choose non-government schools is not because they are better resourced or because of smaller classes. Parents choose because non-government schools because they are faith-based, there is a disciplined environment, strong academic standards and such schools best reflect the needs and aspirations of their local communities.
Catholic schools, in particular, define their mission in terms of the moral and spiritual teachings of the church and, in a time of societal dysfunction and loss of meaning, provide a strong moral compass for students.
Thousands of Australian families embrace school choice with Australian Bureau of Statistics fugures showing just over 30 per cent of students across Australia attending non-government schools the figure rises to more than 40 per cent at years 11 and 12 in the ACT, Victoria and NSW. And between 1998 and 2008, government school enrolments grew by only 1.1 per cent, while the figure for the non-government school sector is 21.9 per cent.
Non-government school parents also save the taxpayer billions of dollars every year. The average cost to governments of educating a student in a state school, based on 2005-06 Productivity Commission figures, is $11,243. The cost to government of educating a student in a non-government school is only $6287. Every student that attends a non-government school saves government (and the taxpayer) about $5000.
Based on the picture painted by critics, one could be forgiven for thinking that already wealthy non-government schools are over-funded by government. The reality is that under the socio-economic status model, funding is means tested. Wealthy schools, measured by a sample survey of parents by a school's postcode, only receive 13.5 per cent of the average cost of educating a government school student.
The Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations assesses each non-government school's wealth by analysing the socio-economic status of a sample of parents whose children are enrolled in the school. As a result, the most financially well-off schools only receive 13.5 per cent of the average cost of educating a government school student.
One of the key elements of Prime Minister Kevin Rudd's education revolution is to raise standards and strengthen school performance. Research, both here and overseas, concludes that one of the characteristics of stronger performing education systems are well resourced, autonomous, non-government schools.
Gary Marks, from the Australian Council for Educational Research, even after adjusting for students' socioeconomic background, concludes that non-government schools achieve better academic results, have higher completion rates and are more successful at getting students into university.
The European researcher, Ludger Woessman, based on an analysis of the OECD's Program for International Student Assessment (PISA), argues that the autonomy and flexibility associated with Catholic and independent schools, unlike state schools that are government controlled, give them an edge in terms of performance.
At the state level, the Victorian Government should be congratulated for signing-off on a $2.1 billion funding deal with non-government schools ($401 million represents new funding).
Given that the Commonwealth Government provides the lion's share of taxpayer funding to non-government schools (about 75 per cent), one hopes that next year's review of the Commonwealth SES funding model will provide an opportunity to reaffirm a commitment to properly fund non-government schools.
One also hopes, for the benefit of Catholic and independent students and their families, that governments do not impose so many conditions on funding that non-government schools lose their independence and ability to best reflect the needs and aspirations of their communities. After all, if non-government schools are made to imitate government schools, the whole point of diversity and school choice is lost.

Dr Kevin Donnelly is director of Education Standards Institute (ESI), a new conservative education webpage recently established www.edstandards.com.au. He is also the author of Australia's Education Revolution: How Kevin Rudd Won and Lost the Education Wars.

 

Responses to this Post

Reply

 

Archived Posts

> Tame the black dog
> Non-government school win the day
> National curriculum review
> Cultural-left rules education
> Fix rowdy classrooms
> Beware the black dog
> Meritocracy good - OK
> Overcoming depression
> Rudd government removing barnacles
> Purpose of education
> Judeo-Christian values ignored
> Myths, fables and legends
> No more victimhood
> Gillard wrong to copy Blair
> Media bias against non-government schools
> Direct Instruction best
> Cultural literacy rules
> UK curriculum back to basics
> Bonus pay for teachers - a bad idea
> Gonski Report released
> Non-government schools in danger
> Gonski a threst to school funding
>
>
> test
> Gillard's education revolution a failure
> School choice good
> Why gays/lesbians should not marry
> Garrett endorses school choice
> Gonski research papers a danger to non-government schools
> School funding and politics of envy
> Wheeler Centre public/private school funding debate
> Julia Gillard fails as Prime Minister
> Mad as a cut snake as insulting as meow!
> Wheeler Centre school funding debate
> Gillard budget 'F' for education
> Non-government schools deserve funding
> Rude students destroy teaching
> PM Julia Gillard not a social conservative
> My School 2.0 will be used to cut funding to non-government schools
> Gillard cannot be trusted on school funding
> 'F' for teaching standards
> Australia - celebrate Western heritage and Christian tradition
> Rudd/Gillard education revolution - fail!
> Non-government schools promote equity
> Non-government schools promote equity and success
> Faith based schools have the right to discriminate
> National curriculum should not be compulsory
> Gillard Government drops education revolution
> Gillard cannot hide her socialist past
> Gillard's funding promise cannot be believed
> Myths and lies about school funding
> Give all schools autonomy and promote school choice
> ALP can't be trusted on school funding
> Islamic curriculum one sided and biased
> Julia Gillard's Geography new-age and PC
> Julia Gillard left-wing and as guilty as Rudd
> Julia Gillard - political opportunist
> History wars
> ALP's education revolution flawed and counter-productive
> New York example has failed
> national testing educationally unsound
> High social mobility in OZ
> I often have doubts about..
> History curriculum PC and dumbed down
> national curriculum English C+
> Gillard refuses to support non-government schools
> testing and ranking schools is flawed
> Similar to Australia, where many..
> School league tables bad
> Published in Education Review..
> Is there an educationa..
> The problem of badly behaved students..
> Extract from book in Weekend Australian..
> School autonomy the way to go
> Julia Gillard, the Commonwealth..
> Why I left the lefties
> Why I am a conservative
> Why the Bishop is wrong on faith and rights

Sign in and have your say

Email:
Password:
Register

Latest Blog

23rd November 2009

In the following article posted on the National Times site I argue why Catholic and independent schools must be properly funded.Independent schools are bastions of equality and toleranceNovember 23,...
Read Full Post!

Shop

$20.00 plus $6 postage
(within Australia).

Latest News


1st January 1970
...

Read entire article...

Sign up to our Newsletter...

donate